← Ask Gina something else

Partner won't get help? The fixer and the fixed

By · Last updated

When your partner won't get help and you keep trying to fix it, the help and the refusal may each be protecting something, and neither is the problem alone.

Rules this may be

One of you mentions a hard day. The other has three suggestions before the sentence is finished. The first one goes quiet, or says they didn't ask for advice. The second one is hurt, since they were only trying to help. The more they did, the more I hold back.

This page is for both of you.

01

What each of you does

One of you solves. You research, you plan, you make the call they were putting off. When they don't take the advice, you offer it again, more clearly.

One of you declines. You say you've got it. You do it your own way, sometimes the slower way, and sometimes you stop mentioning problems at all.

People call the first one controlling and the second one stubborn. Both words are about behavior.

The cost falls on both of you. The one who fixes can end up tired and unthanked. The one who is being fixed can end up feeling worked on. And hard days can stop getting mentioned.

02

What may be under the fixing

Needed

"If they didn't need me, why would I be here?"

Solving it may be how you have a place. Under Needed, the fear is that without your usefulness there is no reason for you. Help that is turned down may land hard.

Read about Needed →
Right

"Being wrong isn't a mistake. It feels like a verdict."

You may be unable to watch it done a way you think is wrong. Under Right, the fear is that if you are wrong about this, what else are you wrong about.

Read about Right →

03

What may be under the refusing

Right

Being advised may sound like being told you were doing it wrong. The fear is the same one, this time on the receiving end.

Read about Right →
Strong

"Strong is the only version of me they know."

Being helped may mean being seen not managing. Under Strong, the fear is that if they see you struggle, you lose the only standing you have.

Read about Strong →

Other rules can sit on either side, and it may be none of these.

04

How the two can lock together

The more one of you helps, the more the other may feel looked at as someone who can't cope, and the more firmly they refuse.

The more one of you refuses, the less the other may feel there is any place for them, and the harder they try to be useful.

Each of you may be reading the other's move as a comment on yourself.

05

A question for each of you

Answer for yourself only.

For the one who fixes, between Needed and Right. Which stings more: that they did it without you, or that they did it wrong? Without you is the Needed answer. Wrong is the Right answer.

For the one who refuses, between Right and Strong. Which is harder to have people see: that you got it wrong, or that you're struggling? Got it wrong is the Right answer. Struggling is the Strong answer.

If neither answer comes, there is not enough to tell yet. That is a result.

Not all of this is a rule. Sometimes one of you does know more about the thing in question. Sometimes a person only wants to be heard, and says so, and that is an ordinary preference.

Subtraction would not ask which of you is right about the advice. It would ask what each move is for, and remove the answers that don't hold.

A neighboring loop, where one of you gives way and the other keeps to the facts, is on The Peacekeeper and the One Who Needs to Be Right.

Your next step

Read this one page next.

Just one. You don't have to read them all.

More like this (2)How the Needed rule shows up in relationshipsThe peacekeeper and the one who needs to be right

Looking for a person to work with? See how we check practitioners →

When this may need professional support. If what you are dealing with includes self-harm, severe depression or anxiety, substance dependence, or trauma symptoms that disrupt daily life, licensed mental-health care is the right door. Project Gina does not replace it. In the US, call or text 988.
Next stepRescuing →